Yes
A total change of direction here
For as long as I can remember
I have been fascinated by whales
All animals really
But especially whales
It started when I did a project on them in primary school
And the fascination has never left me
There is something so magical about them
Their sheer size alone is mind boggling
Last night on BBC
There was a documentary on about zoos
Presented by Liz Bonin
That asked the questions
Should we keep animals in captivity?
What are the costs and the benefits?
I wasn't going to watch said documentary
As in the trailer
It said there were some upsetting scenes
And nothing upsets me more than seeing animals in distress
I decided to watch it though
As even though it is really upsetting
I want to be aware of what is happening
The documentary itself was brilliant
It asked some really tough questions
About why we keep animals in captivity
Their habitat in captivity
Their behaviour in captivity as opposed to the wild
Apparently an elephants life span is cut in half in captivity
They also experience other problems such as obesity
Rotten teeth
And foot problems
All because they have been kept in the wrong sort of conditions
The documentary also questions about extinction
In the case of the northern white rhino
There are none left in the wild at all
And only five exist in captivity
So
Is it better to keep a species in captivity to keep it alive?
Or should we allow these beautiful animals to die out?
It's a tricky one
But back to whales
The documentary spoke about the movie Black Fish
The film that focuses on the events that led up to the death of 40 year old Seaworld trainer Dawn Branchaeu in 2010
I haven't seen the movie
As I think it would send me over the edge and traumatise me for life
The name of the whale that killed Dawn Brancheau is called Tilikum
Dawn was rubbing Tilikum as part of a post show routine when the orca grabbed her by her left arm and hair
And dragged her to the bottom of the enclosure
Tilikum scalped her
Broke her bones
Dismembered her
She drowned
The third person to have been killed by Tilikum since his capture over 30 years ago
Seaworld declined to take part in the film Black Fish
But they did agree to an interview for the BBC documentary last night
We got to meet Tilikum
Who still resides in Sea World
The head vet there
Argued that Dawn Brancheaus death was a tragic accident
And not a deliberate attack on her life
Let's rewind here a little
So I can give you some history of Tilikum
Tilikum is the largest orca in captivity
Weighing in at 12, 500 pounds
And over 22 feet in length
Tilikum was captured near Iceland
In November 1983
Two years old
He was ripped away from his family and ocean home
He was covered in lanolin
An oil extracted from sheeps wool which is applied to the orcas whole body to prepare them for a long transport without water
Tilikum has been bought and sold like a commodity since his capture
Held in small holding tanks
All he could do was swim in small circles and float aimlessly at the surface of the water
In the wild an orca can cover an area of up to 100 miles a day
So you can see how disturbing it must be to the whale
In captivity
Food was held from Tilikum as a training technique
He was forced to perform every hour on the hour
8 times a day
7 days a week
On February 21 1991 Sealand trainer Keltie Byrne fell in to a pool containing three orcas including Tilikum
She was pulled to the bottom of the enclosure
Tossed around among the three orcas
And ultimately drowned
She was the first of three people to have been killed due to Tilikums stress, confinement and frustration
After the death of Keltie
Sealand closed its doors for good
And Tilikum was sold to Seaworld
Over the course of Tilikums life at there
He has been involved in multiple acts of aggression
The stress of captivity also drives him to exhibit abnormal repetitive behaviour
Such as on metal gates and the concrete sides of his tank
The stress of captivity also drove Tilikum to kill a young trainer called Daniel P Dukes in 1999
Following Dawns tragic death in 2010
Tilikum was kept in a tiny enclosure
After a year of isolation
He returned to performing
Aggression towards humans by orcas is almost non existent in nature
But the constant stress of living in incompatible social groupings inside minuscule tAnks at Seaworld causes them to lash out
Posing a threat of danger to other whales and employees alike
Having researched this topic today
And some of the information here was taken directly from Seaworld of Hurts website
I feel a sense of despair for these animals
It really upsets me
In fact cruelty to animals upsets me a lot more than cruelty to people
I asked myself today
What I can do to help these poor creatures
And I guess by raising awareness here on my blog is at least something
I find myself with little pity for those that Tilikum killed
I mean these are wild animals
Being kept in unsatisfactory conditions
I'm actually surprised that more people haven't been killed
So I guess we need to ask ourselves some difficult questions
In order to solve this problem
In my opinion
Seaworld and similar places should be illegal
No more than dancing bears
Donkey rides
And any other activity that exploits animals for money
As humans
We do not own this planet
Animals have every right to life in the wild
As it seems keeping them in captivity does not work
With all that said
I was wondering about you
What do you think about places like Seaworld?
Have you ever been?
And also what do you think about zoos?
I know a lot of you out there are animal lovers like me
So I am interested to hear what you think...