Monday 12 August 2013

Black Swan

I never sleep well on a Sunday night for a number of reasons so last night I was hunting through the house for Dvds to see me through the night as painless as possible
I was looking for something undemanding like a rom-com but then I stumbled across Black Swan
I have seen it before but it was in hospital so you can forgive me for  not giving it my full attention
I was hesitant as first to watch it for a couple of reasons
The number one being that I find it really hard to watch dancing
Not because it is triggering (although it can be)
But because I find it upsetting to watch others do what I wanted to and should have done
If things had gone differently in my life, I would have persued a career in dance
If not dancing itself, then teaching
So watching others do it makes me sad and envious and angry

I'd forgotten how good this film is
I'm sure most of you have seen it but if not Black Swan is a dark psychological thriller directed by Darren Aronofsky
The plot revolves around a production of Tchaikovsk's Swan Lake ballet by a prestigious New York company
The production requires the chosen ballerina to preform the role of the innocent and fragile White Swan, for which the committed dancer Nina is a perfect fit, as well as the dark and sensual Black Swan, which are qualities embodied by new arrival Lily
Nina puts massive pressure on herself to compete for the role and her quest for perfection which ultimately causes her to lose her tenuous grip on reality and her dream begins to turn in to a living nightmare



As the pressure on Nina mounts, she begins to hallucinate and she also self harms
When I saw the scene of her feet either side of of a toilet bowl I figure that shehad bulimia also
I can't think of any other reason why they would show that
Nina is haunted by Lily who she thinks is trying to replace her
The night before her debut performance, Lily takes Nina out drinking and gives her pills
Later we see them having sex but when Nina wakes up in the morning Lily has vanished
Nina descends in to a world where she can't distinguish what is real
She is terrified but determined to perform than night

During the performance she hallucinates during a lift and falls
In her dressing room comes to tell that she will be dancing the rest of the performance
Nina cracks and shoves her in to  a mirror, smashing it
She stabs Lily with a shard of glass
Panicking, she hides Lily's body in the bathroom and continues with the show
At last she manages to conquer the character of the Black Swan and she finishes the first act to thunderous applause
But by this stage she seems to have completely lost her grip on reality



She goes back to her dressing room to check on Lily but when she gets there the body is gone and Lily seems to be fine
She looks down and realises that the shard of glass was actually in her
She had stabbed herself
Somehow she finishes the performance
At the end, when the Swan commits suicide, Nina jumps from the platform on to a mattress
Her last words were 'I felt it. Perfect. I was perfect'

I thought this film was darkly beautiful
Natalie Portman was utterly stunning as Nina and thoroughly deserved the Oscar that year
Her dancing was mesmerising
She did take ballet as a child and underwent a year of intensive training to prepare for the role of Nina
She did have a dance double though, an ABT dancer called Sarah Lane
I though the portrayal of her losing her mind was done really well
It was subtle at first
You weren't quite sure if you saw what you thought you saw
The eyes in a picture moving
A distorted image in a mirror
And over time her world turns upside down

It was Nina's pursuit of perfection that was her downfall
I think many of us fall in the trap of trying to be perfect
The perfect daughter
The perfect sibling
The perfect friend
The perfect job
And of course the perfect body
Nina obviously had an eating disorder
When she is having her measurements taken, we see give a little smile when the lady tells her that she has lost weight
There is something about ballet that brings out a persons need to be perfect
I remember when I took ballet from the age of 10 - 16
Having to wear a leotard and tights there is no hiding your body
And in a room full of mirrors there is no getting away from having to look at your own body
I remember my ballet teacher telling my mother that I was losing weight
I had no idea why but that made me feel good
Maybe it was because I was fed the message that thinner is better
Maybe it was the attention and the concern
Whatever the reason it was a sign of things to come

I remember really looking forward to doing pointe work
The day I got my first pair of pointe shoes is one that I will always remember
It's important to get shoes that fit your feet perfectly and it can take time to find the right pair
Before you use you have to break them in
Literally break the spine of the shoe
Then darn the pointe
Sew on ribbons
All this before you even put them on
I didn't get to do much pointe work and never really properly danced in them
Some say it is barbaric to wear them
They ruin your feet
Even though it looks delicate and beautiful to watch someone dance in them, it is incredibly difficult
It takes such control and strength
I think dancers are athletes
I remember when I was taking ballet our teacher used to take us to the gym for a punishing work out
I wanted to be perfect
Perfect lines
Perfect turn out
Perfect poise
Unfortunately perfection is impossible
If we expect perfection then we will be bitterly disappointed

I got a distinction in my first ballet exam
And after that I put pressure on myself to make sure that I always got no less than a distinction
Obviously I was no where near the league that Nina was dancing in but it was still a stress in my life
In my next two exams I got 2 more distinctions
But then in grade 5 I got a merit
I was devastated
I felt that I had failed
Fuel for my developing eating disorder
In grade 6 I began to lose interest in dancing
I was distracted by friends and boys and began to dabble in drugs
I remember the day  that I went to collect my exam results
There was 3 of us in the class and our teacher told us at the beginning of the class that 2 of us had passed with a merit and one had achieved a distinction
I was massively hung over and didn't really care what I had got
But it turned out that I had got the distinction
I gave up ballet soon after that
Something that I've always regretted

I've always had a perfectionist streak
It can be a good thing as it means you do things diligently and thoroughly
But it also means that you put huge pressure on yourself and are often very hard on yourself
As with my addiction and ED, it's an all or nothing game
Either be brilliant at something or don't do it at all
The mind is a fragile thing and will only take so much
It 's a terrifying feeling to feel like you are losing your mind
It happened to me just recently when I really thought that I was going mad
In reality it was a combination of lack of food and isolating
I went to my mother an told her that I was worried about myself
That I felt like I was going crazy and maybe needed to go in to hospital
She managed to appease me and calm me down
But it is always there in the back of my mind
The fear of losing touch with reality

Have you see Black Swan?
What did you think of it?

12 comments:

  1. I never saw the movie in full, I watched part of it... it was quite sad and yes Natalie portrayed the role wonderfully.

    What is is about some of us and perfectionism... because I couldn't control my weight I ate instead... Now I am controlling everything about my body, I hope when I reach my goal, I will give a little... I think I will... but I wonder sometimes...

    Perfection is a myth, I know this but yet I seek after it...

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is a myth Launna
    And I've discovered that I don't want perfection
    Perfection is boring
    It's our quirks and foibles and flaws that make us who we are
    If we were all perfect the world would be a very boring place

    Hope you are well x

    ReplyDelete
  3. I saw it and loved it. I'm a huge psychological thriller fan. There were a lot of dynamics going on: her relationship with her mother, the conflict between perfection and happiness, what's happiness, sexuality, all that. You have to kill this or that side. I get your need for perfection. I was first in my class and went over and above for it. I played sports to be liked. I did things I didn't fully enjoy to be perfect. It's not worth it. You know, there's never an age limit on dancing.:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love these kinds of thrillers too Eve, much scarier than a horror film
      Yes the relationship between Nina and her mother was interesting
      Her mother had given up ballet to have Nina

      You are right, there is no joy in trying and failing to be perfect
      And yes, there is no age limit in dance
      I guess my thinking was if I can't be amazing then I don't want to do it at all
      But I know I could do it for fun and that would be enough x

      Delete
    2. You just gave me an "ah ha!" Moment. I do that too. If I can't be perfect or amazing, what's the point? My trainer has been telling me that it's the journey, not the destination. <3

      Delete
  4. I didn't realize that you had taken dancing lessons! I took ballet when I was very young, about 6 years old. I didn't like it for some reason, so I quit after a year. Now, I wish i could take some ballet lessons, because I just like to dance in general and it would be fun to learn some elementary ballet moves.
    I have seen Black Swan and I liked it. I related a lot to Nina. I thought that the hints of her eating disorder were subtle and very much in the background to her overall psychological breakdown, which I kind of liked. It shows that eating disorders and other kinds of psychosis are not black blotches in an otherwise rosy existence.

    ReplyDelete
  5. When I saw Black Swan I was mesmerized. When the film was over I just stared and stared at the screen. I wanted to burn into my memory everything I just saw. I liked it so well I was Black Swan for Halloween two years in a row. I remember being somewhat triggered, but I've danced my whole life so I was like "yep... yep... yep..." for everything that happened. I put a huge amount of blame on ballet for my eating disorder. At the same time I wouldn't go back and undo it for anything. I wouldn't be ME if it weren't for dance. Now I teach Zumba. About as far from ballet as you can get, but I enjoy using my body to express myself.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm in love with this movie. There are so many things about it that they explore- sex, masturbation, eating disorders/body image, relations with your parents, self freedom- in such an amazing portrayal. I saw this in theaters right before I graduated, and in a particularly bath throw of self loathing and ED and it was like it was meant for me practically. I could go on and on about it. One of my favorite movies ever and now I want to go watch it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Natalie portman did not do the dancing, a proffesional ballerina did it as a stunt. Natalie was 28 yrs old, she exercised for a year to make her body LOOK like a ballerinas body. It is simply impossible to catch up with 8grs training per day,6 days a week for at least 10-15 yrs at the impossible age of 28 in just one year. The film was decent, but what people made of it and natalie portmans performance in regards to "dancing" is a scandal. It micks the intensity and incredible hard work over years and years of all proffesional dancers.

    Sry needed to be said! Hope you are ok ruby, all the best,!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I want to see this movie but honestly I have been scared to watch it. I do love psychological thrillers, I find them scarier than any other movies. I don't know if I could watch this right now.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I adore that movie in SO MANY WAYS it's ridiculous.

    I love the dancing (I saw a special features bit about the amount of CG they ahd to use for the dancing scenes. Portman was only used for waist-up shots/closeups/face shots in dancing. Most of what you saw in the movie was actually Lane.)

    Damn but I could spot EVERY SINGLE TIME reality got blurry the first time I watched it. I've had too much experience with hallucinations and things getting weird. Also, doing 5 film studies and living with an aspiring director doesn't help.

    Can you use dancing again to help you get physically healthy enough to buy yourself time to deal the death-blow to the monster killing you? You've probably tried it already but I had to say it again >.<

    Luffles you Ruby <3

    ReplyDelete
  10. I guess I need to see this movie.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for leaving some love x